Grading Guidelines:
If you are not familiar with comic grading, this page will help you understand how we assess the condition of our comics. We use a standard grading scale, from Mint (flawless) to Poor (heavily worn), to ensure you’re fully informed about the quality of the comic before making a purchase. Our goal is to provide transparency so you can shop with confidence!
Gem Mint (10.0)
- Page Color: Perfect white, bright, and vibrant.
- Spine Condition: Absolutely no stress lines, bends, or spine ticks.
- Staples: Perfectly centered and pristine; no rust or stress around the staple areas.
- Description: Flawless. No defects visible even under magnification.
Mint (9.9)
- Page Color: Pristine white pages.
- Spine Condition: Near-perfect with only a barely noticeable stress or bindery flaw.
- Staples: Clean, well-centered, and rust-free.
- Description: Almost perfect condition with a tiny manufacturing defect.
Near Mint/Mint (9.8)
- Page Color: White or off-white.
- Spine Condition: Just a faint spine stress or a minor imperfection.
- Staples: No rust, no stress tears; perfectly positioned.
- Description: Essentially new with only the tiniest flaws visible on close inspection.
Near Mint+ (9.6)
- Page Color: White to off-white.
- Spine Condition: Almost perfect, maybe a couple of faint spine ticks.
- Staples: Secure and rust-free.
- Description: Only minor handling wear, with sharp corners and a glossy cover.
Near Mint (9.4)
- Page Color: Off-white to white.
- Spine Condition: A few small stress marks, minimal wear.
- Staples: No rust, slight signs of handling near staples.
- Description: Minor wear that can be seen under close inspection but still a high-grade comic.
Very Fine/Near Mint (9.2)
- Page Color: Slightly off-white.
- Spine Condition: A few minor spine stresses, minor corner dings.
- Staples: Secure, no rust, slight stress at staples.
- Description: Minor imperfections that do not detract significantly from the book’s appearance.
Very Fine+ (8.5)
- Page Color: Off-white to cream.
- Spine Condition: Some light spine creases, minor edge wear.
- Staples: No rust, some stress lines near staples.
- Description: Very minor wear, usually small creases or slight corner imperfections.
Very Fine (8.0)
- Page Color: Cream to off-white.
- Spine Condition: A few small stress lines, light edge wear.
- Staples: Clean, but slight stress or slight misalignment is acceptable.
- Description: Noticeable but minor wear. Still has solid eye appeal.
Fine/Very Fine (7.5)
- Page Color: Cream to off-white.
- Spine Condition: Visible spine wear, light corner and edge wear.
- Staples: Secure with minor stress, possible slight misalignment.
- Description: Slightly more visible defects, such as light bends or a few more pronounced creases.
Fine+ (6.5)
- Page Color: Cream to slightly yellowed.
- Spine Condition: More spine creases and minor corner rounding.
- Staples: Minor rust may be starting; staples might not be centered.
- Description: Moderate wear with minor defects that are more visible.
Fine (6.0)
- Page Color: Cream to tan.
- Spine Condition: Moderate spine stress and small corner tears.
- Staples: Some minor rust, possible minor tearing around staples.
- Description: More visible defects such as small tears, minor stains, and corner rounding.
Very Good/Fine (5.5)
- Page Color: Tan to cream.
- Spine Condition: Multiple spine stresses, slight spine roll may be present.
- Staples: Rust starting to show; small stress tears may be visible.
- Description: Moderate wear with more pronounced defects but still complete and structurally sound.
Very Good+ (4.5)
- Page Color: Cream to tan with some discoloration.
- Spine Condition: Noticeable spine creases, edge wear, and small tears.
- Staples: Light rust; stress tears at staples may be present.
- Description: Multiple defects like larger creases, small tears, and heavier spine wear.
Very Good (4.0)
- Page Color: Light tan to brown.
- Spine Condition: Spine creases, small cover tears, and some fading.
- Staples: Minor rust, slight separation from the pages at staples.
- Description: Clearly visible wear but still complete and intact.
Good/Very Good (3.5)
- Page Color: Brown or brittle edges.
- Spine Condition: Heavy spine creasing, slight spine roll.
- Staples: Rusted staples, some tearing at staple points.
- Description: Heavy wear with multiple defects, but still complete.
Good+ (2.5)
- Page Color: Darker tan to brown, more brittle.
- Spine Condition: Large creases, moderate spine roll, and small chunks missing.
- Staples: Heavy rust, possible loose staples.
- Description: Major defects like large creases, moderate tears, and faded colors.
Good (2.0)
- Page Color: Dark tan or brittle pages.
- Spine Condition: Severe spine creasing and spine roll.
- Staples: Heavy rust, may be detached or missing.
- Description: Very worn with major tears, pieces missing, and multiple defects.
Fair/Good (1.5)
- Page Color: Brown and possibly fragile.
- Spine Condition: Extreme wear, multiple tears, and large missing pieces.
- Staples: Heavy rust, often detached or barely holding.
- Description: Heavy damage but still complete and readable.
Fair (1.0)
- Page Color: Dark brown or brittle.
- Spine Condition: Nearly split spine, major pieces missing.
- Staples: Detached or missing entirely.
- Description: Very poor condition, with severe damage and missing parts.
Poor (0.5)
- Page Color: Brittle, flaking, or crumbling.
- Spine Condition: Completely split or missing.
- Staples: Detached, rusted, or missing.
- Description: Incomplete or almost unreadable with major portions missing.